Every October and November, someone asks me whether they can file as single this year. The answer almost never turns on how long they’ve been separated. It turns on one date.

The IRS looks at your marital status on the last day of the tax year. If a Texas court has signed a final decree of divorce by December 31, you’re treated as unmarried for that whole year. If the decree isn’t signed by then, you’re treated as married for that whole year, even if you moved out in February and haven’t spoken since. A temporary order doesn’t change that. Neither does a petition that’s been on file for ten months.

That one rule produces most of the tax questions I hear in a pending divorce. Here’s what the date actually decides.

If you’re still married on December 31

You have two options, and sometimes a third.

Married filing jointly. Both of you report everything on one return. It usually produces the lower combined bill. It also carries joint and several liability, which means the IRS can collect the whole balance from either one of you. A decree assigning the tax to your spouse doesn’t bind the IRS. If your spouse understated income and you signed the return, you can ask the IRS for innocent spouse relief on Form 8857, but that’s a request you have to make and win, not a protection you already hold.

Married filing separately. Each of you reports your own income, and each of you is responsible only for the tax due on your own return. It’s the safer choice when you don’t have confidence in the other side’s numbers. It’s also usually the more expensive one, because separate filers lose or have limited access to a long list of credits and deductions.

Filing separately in Texas comes with a wrinkle people don’t expect. Texas is a community property state, which means most of what either spouse earns during the marriage belongs to both of them, and the IRS follows state law on that question. Spouses who file separate returns in a community property state generally each report half of the community income plus all of their own separate income, and each attaches Form 8958 showing how the split was figured. Texas is also one of a handful of those states that go further: interest, dividends, and rent thrown off by one spouse’s separate property count as community income here too. So filing separately doesn’t mean filing in isolation. You still need numbers from the other household.

Head of household. This is the third option, and it’s narrower than it sounds. The IRS will treat a married person as unmarried for this purpose only if all of the following are true: you file a separate return, you paid more than half the cost of keeping up your home for the year, your spouse did not live in your home at any point during the last six months of the year, and your home was your child’s main home for more than half the year and you can claim that child. Miss one of those and you’re back to married filing separately.

What a Texas court can do about taxes, and what it can’t

A judge dividing your property is allowed to think about tax. Texas Family Code section 7.008 says the court may consider whether a specific asset will be subject to taxation, and if it will be, when that tax has to be paid. It’s an easy thing to overlook, because two accounts with identical balances look identical on a spreadsheet. A hundred thousand dollars in a brokerage account and a hundred thousand in a traditional retirement account hand you very different amounts once the tax is paid, and the retirement account also carries rules about when you can reach it at all. It’s one of the reasons dividing property in a Texas divorce is rarely a matter of adding up balances.

What no decree can do is rewrite federal tax law. It can divide a refund, because a refund generated by income earned during the marriage is part of the marital estate like anything else. It can order one spouse to pay a liability. It can’t stop the IRS from pursuing both signatures on a joint return, and it can’t create a filing status the Internal Revenue Code doesn’t offer.

Which way to go

I’m not going to hand you a rule about whether to push a decree across the line before year end or let it fall into January, because the answer runs on your numbers rather than on a principle. A couple with one high earner and one spouse with almost no income often does better filing jointly one last time. A spouse with no real visibility into the other’s business records often does better filing separately, whatever it costs in deductions. Those two situations point in opposite directions. Sorting out which one you’re in means looking at the actual numbers, usually with your CPA involved.

That’s also where having business counsel in the building changes the work. When a divorce involves a company, rental property, or significant assets, the tax question isn’t an errand to run after the property division is settled. It’s part of the property division. HKH has civil and business attorneys on staff, so the business and tax side of a case gets worked alongside the family law side from the start instead of being sent out and reported back.

One small thing I notice every year. The spouse who moved out is almost always the one without a copy of last year’s return. Ask for it now. It’s a two minute request in November and a two week problem in March.

If your divorce is pending in Collin, Dallas, or Denton county, this is a question worth bringing to a consultation before the end of the year rather than in April, and worth bringing even if your paperwork is still a mess.

Not sure where your situation stands?

We will talk it through with you and explain your options in plain language. No pressure to decide anything.

Schedule a Consultation

Or call 469-598-1080